Shikifuton mattresses—often simply called Japanese futons—are rapidly gaining popularity as a healthy alternative to traditional Western mattresses. Thin, supportive, low to the ground, and crafted from natural materials, shikifutons offer a sleep experience built around alignment, breathability, and simplicity.
But if you are new to this style of sleeping, one question inevitably arises: Should I choose a 3-inch or a 5-inch shikifuton?
While a mere two inches might not sound like much, it makes a significant difference in how the mattress feels and performs. This guide breaks down the key differences between the two thicknesses and matches each one to the ideal sleep style—stomach, back, and side sleepers—so you can choose the perfect natural futon for your needs.
Why Shikifutons Are Designed Thin
To the uninitiated, sleeping on a mattress that is only a few inches thick might seem counterintuitive. However, traditional Japanese shikibutons are intentionally designed this way. They are typically around 3 inches thick and filled with breathable, natural fibers like cotton, wool, and latex.
Unlike Western mattresses-which are often thick blocks of polyurethane foam and chemical flame retardants-shikibutons use natural, supportive materials that keep your spine aligned instead of letting your body sag into a "hammock" shape.
At The Futon Shop, every shikibuton is handcrafted from organic, naturally fire-resistant materials, including certified cotton, natural wool, natural latex, and PLA fiber.
Correct spinal alignment
Chemical-free sleep
Temperature regulation
Portability
3-Inch vs. 5-Inch: What’s the Real Difference?
Both thicknesses offer the same high-quality natural materials and craftsmanship. The difference comes down to firmness, pressure relief, and how "close to the floor" you want to feel.
The 3-Inch Shikibuton: Firm & Traditional
This option is the closest you can get to the traditional Japanese sleep experience. It is firm, minimalist, and incredibly lightweight. Because there is less material between you and the floor (or tatami mat), the surface feels very stable.
Best for:
- Sleepers who love a truly firm surface.
- People looking for the lightest, most portable option.
- Minimalists who fold and store their bed away every single morning.
The 5-Inch Shikifuton: Plush & Versatile
The 5-inch model adds extra cushioning and pressure relief. It serves as a gentle transition for those used to Western mattresses. It is still low and supportive—never "soft" in the way a memory foam mattress is—but it provides just enough give to cradle the hips and shoulders.
Best for:
- Side sleepers needing pressure point relief.
- Guest beds (more universally comfortable for visitors).
- Sleepers transitioning from soft Western mattresses.
The Best Shikifuton Thickness for Your Sleep Style
Choosing the right height depends heavily on how you sleep. Here is our breakdown based on common sleep positions.
Best for Stomach Sleepers: 3-Inch Shikifuton
Stomach sleepers require a firm, stable surface. If a mattress is too soft, the hips will dip down, causing the lower back to arch uncomfortably. This strain is a leading cause of morning back pain for stomach sleepers.
Why the 3-inch works: The thinner profile keeps the spine in a neutral position. It prevents the hips from sinking, ensuring your back stays flat and aligned.
Top Recommendations:
Best for Back Sleepers: It Depends on Preference
Back sleepers have the most flexibility. Your choice depends on whether you prefer the feeling of sleeping "on" your mattress or "in" it.
If you prefer firm support: Choose the 3-inch for traditional floor-sleeping support. This is excellent for keeping the shoulders open and the spine straight.
If you prefer a bit of cushion: Choose the 5-inch for a softer, more forgiving feel that fills the gap in the lumbar region slightly more than the thinner version.
Top Recommendations:
Best for Side Sleepers: 5-Inch Shikifuton
Side sleeping puts the most pressure on specific points of the body—specifically the shoulders and hips. A surface that is too thin or hard can cause numbness in the arms or pain in the hip joints.
Why the 5-inch works: Side sleepers need that extra depth. The added material allows the hips and shoulders to sink in slightly, relieving pressure while still supporting the waist and alignment.
Top Recommendations:
Understanding the Materials
The feel of your shikifuton isn't just about thickness; it's about what's inside.
Organic Cotton
The most traditional fill. It is dense, firm, and packs down over time. Ideal for those who want a truly authentic, hard surface.
Organic Wool
Offers a balance of soft and firm. It is incredible at temperature regulation, keeping you cool in summer and warm in winter. It has more "cushion" than cotton.
Latex
&
Wool
The most durable and comfortable option for everyday use. The latex core prevents the mattress from bottoming out, adding buoyancy and longevity.
Latex
&
PLA
Similar to the latex and wool blend but uses potato-based PLA fiber. This is excellent for vegans or those with wool sensitivities.
How to Maintain Your Shikifuton
Because these mattresses are made of natural fibers without chemical stabilizers, they require a little more care than a standard box spring mattress. But the payoff—a cleaner, healthier sleep—is worth it.
1. Pair with Tatami Mats: Proper airflow is critical. Placing your shikifuton on tatami mats allows air to circulate underneath, preventing mold and mildew.
2. Roll or Fold Daily: In Japan, the bed is folded up every morning. This isn't just to save space; it helps "fluff" the fibers and maintain the loft of the cotton and wool.
3. Rotate Regularly: To prevent body impressions from forming in the same spot, rotate your mattress head-to-toe frequently.
4. Sun Your Futon: Occasionally putting your shikifuton in the sun (if possible) helps sanitize the natural fibers and restore fluffiness.
Which Will You Choose?
Whether you choose a 3-inch or 5-inch shikifuton, you are making a choice for better health. Both options offer cleaner ingredients, better spinal alignment, and the handcrafted quality The Futon Shop is known for.
If you want a firmer, traditional feel, choose the 3-inch.
If you want comfort, cushion, and versatility, choose the 5-inch.
Ready to transform your sleep?
Explore The Futon Shop's full collection of handcrafted, natural shikifutons today.
EXPLORE OUR COLLECTION
